![Integral [+] Facticity](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_80,h_80,c_fill,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep,g_auto/https%3A%2F%2Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8458843-3278-4fcc-accc-17ad21352205_1280x1280.png)
![Integral [+] Facticity](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_36,h_36,c_fill,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep,g_auto/https%3A%2F%2Fbucketeer-e05bbc84-baa3-437e-9518-adb32be77984.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8458843-3278-4fcc-accc-17ad21352205_1280x1280.png)
The Limits of Lifestyle Enclaves
A Critique of Integral Life
Summary
This essay serves a dual purpose: to honour my late teacher, Michel Despland, and to provide an introduction to Robert Bellah's research on Sheilaism and lifestyle enclaves. Additionally, this essay will offer a critique of an ongoing public relations issue related to Ken Wilber's work, which has notably impeded its acceptance within traditional academic circles and generated resistance regarding its incorporation into some of my ongoing research interests and online projects.
Introduction: Conversations with Galen Watts & Matteo Bortolini
As listeners of my podcast, Integral Facticity, know, I had the immense pleasure of interviewing Galen Watts and Matteo Bortolini about the work and life of Robert Bellah. Galen Watts is a distinguished scholar with a research focus on contemporary spirituality, religion, and culture. He critically examines the interplay between these elements and modern society, particularly through the lenses of individualism and authenticity. His work often explores the intersections of personal belief systems with broader sociocultural trends. Additionally, his academic insights have been enriched by studying under the esteemed Canadian political philosopher Will Kymlicka. Galen has recently published a new book titled "The Shape of Spirituality: The Public Significance of a Religious Transformation", which I am looking forward to reading shortly. Moreover, I was pleased to learn that Galen has recently been appointed as an Assistant Professor in the Department of Sociology and Legal Studies at the University of Waterloo.
Matteo Bortolini, conversely, is a sociologist with a profound interest in intellectual history and the development of social theory. His research delves into the works of significant figures in sociology and philosophy, aiming to uncover the historical contexts and intellectual movements that have influenced their thoughts. Bortolini's contributions to the field are marked by his thorough and insightful analyses of these influential thinkers. His book, "A Joyfully Serious Man: The Life of Robert Bellah" (Princeton University Press, 2021) received the 2022 Distinguished Publication Award from the American Sociological Association.
Discovering Robert Bellah Through Michel Despland
My introduction to Robert Bellah's work was significantly influenced by my relationship with Michel Despland during my time at Concordia University. Despland, a renowned scholar in the field of religious studies, encouraged me to explore the intersection of religion, culture, and society. His teachings emphasized the importance of understanding the cultural and historical context of religious beliefs, which led me to delve deeper into the study of religion and society. Despland's influence was instrumental in shaping my intellectual journey and research interests, guiding me towards Bellah's contributions to the sociology of religion.
Michel Despland: A Mentor and Influential Scholar
Michel Despland was born in 1936 in Lausanne, Switzerland. He completed his undergraduate studies in theology in Lausanne and Edinburgh, Scotland, and earned his master's and doctorate degrees at Harvard University while studying with towering figures such as Paul Tillich and Wilfred Cantwell Smith. Despland joined Sir George Williams University, one of Concordia's founding institutions, as a lecturer in the Department of Religion in 1965. Over the next 40 years, he filled many roles, including professor, department chair, associate dean of Arts, associate dean of Research, director of graduate programs, and founding member of the Liberal Arts College. His contributions to the field of religious studies in Quebec and Canada were significant, and he was remembered as a giant in the field by his colleagues and students. Despland's work on the history of religious thought and his emphasis on interdisciplinary approaches and critical thinking profoundly shaped my academic interests.
Lifestyle Enclaves and Sheilaism in Bellah's Work
Robert Bellah's theory of “lifestyle enclaves” and “Sheilaism” versus traditional religion provides a profound analysis of the shift in modern society towards individualism and personal fulfillment. According to Bellah, this shift has resulted in the creation of lifestyle enclaves, which markedly differ from traditional religious communities. These enclaves are social groups that coalesce around shared interests, hobbies, or lifestyles, rather than deep communal bonds or shared moral commitments. They are often characterized by an emphasis on individualism, consumerism, and transient connections.
Sheilaism: A Case Study in Individualistic Spirituality
Bellah introduced the concept of Sheilaism in his seminal work, "Habits of the Heart," through the story of Sheila Larson, a nurse who had crafted her own personal religion. Sheila's faith was a blend of various spiritual ideas and practices that suited her individual needs and worldview. She described it simply as "Sheilaism," encapsulating a highly personalized form of spirituality that resonated with her sense of self. This phenomenon was not unique to Sheila; it reflected a broader trend where individuals increasingly move away from traditional, organized religions to create their own spiritual paths, tailored to their subjective experiences and preferences.
Sheilaism is emblematic of a significant shift in contemporary spirituality – a move towards self-defined faiths that prioritize personal fulfillment over communal belonging. This individualistic approach often includes elements borrowed from various religious traditions, creating a patchwork of beliefs and practices. For instance, someone might meditate following Buddhist techniques, practice yoga, and pray the rosary, all while adhering to no single religious doctrine comprehensively.
Implications of Individualistic Spirituality
The rise of Sheilaism and similar spiritual practices has profound implications for both individuals and society. On a personal level, this trend allows for greater freedom and flexibility in spiritual expression, enabling people to find meaning and comfort in ways that resonate deeply with their individual experiences. However, it can also lead to a sense of isolation, as the communal aspect of traditional religious practice diminishes.
From a societal perspective, the proliferation of individualistic spiritualities can contribute to the fragmentation of social cohesion. Traditional religious communities often provide a keen sense of belonging and support systems that foster social bonds and communal responsibilities. As more people turn to personalized spirituality, these communal structures weaken, potentially leading to decreased social solidarity.
Examples of Modern Sheilaism
Modern examples of Sheilaism can be seen in the growing number of people identifying as "spiritual but not religious". These individuals often engage in practices like mindfulness meditation, holistic healing, and personal development workshops. They might attend spiritual retreats, follow inspirational social media accounts, and read self-help books that combine spiritual advice with practical life tips.
For instance, the rise of wellness communities, such as those focused on holistic health and fitness, often blends spiritual practices with lifestyle choices. These groups may gather for yoga sessions that incorporate meditation and philosophy derived from Eastern traditions, creating a collective yet individualistic experience.
Similarly, the popularity of personalized spiritual practices and the resurgence of interest in practices like tarot and psychic readings reflect the desire for tailored spiritual guidance and connections. These practices allow individuals to explore spirituality on their own terms, often without the constraints of formal religious doctrine.
Critique of Integral Life as a Lifestyle Enclave
Ken Wilber's integral community and movement, often called Integral Life, can be considered a lifestyle enclave. Integral Life is a community of individuals who share a deep interest in Ken Wilber's integral theory and its application to various aspects of life, including personal growth, spirituality, psychology, and social issues. The community emphasizes personal development and self-improvement through practices such as meditation and mindfulness. Members are encouraged to explore and integrate different dimensions of their lives, including their inner experiences and external actions. Integral Life offers a range of resources, including courses, events, media, and practice groups, that cater to the interests and needs of its members. These activities are often centered around the consumption of content and participation in events that align with the community's values.
While the community fosters a sense of belonging and shared purpose, the connections within the community can be more transient and less deeply rooted compared to traditional religious communities. Members may come and go based on their personal interests and life circumstances. Integral Life operates primarily as a digital media community, allowing individuals from around the world to connect and engage with content and each other. This global reach further emphasizes the focus on shared interests rather than deep, localized communal bonds.
In summary, Ken Wilber's integral community and movement exhibit many characteristics of a lifestyle enclave, with a focus on shared interests, personal fulfillment, and consumer-oriented activities. While it provides a sense of belonging and purpose, the connections within the community may be more superficial and transient compared to traditional religious communities.
Conclusion: Separating Ken Wilber's Work from Integral Life
Robert Bellah's contributions to the sociology of religion, particularly his concepts of Sheilaism and lifestyle enclaves, have had a lasting impact on the field. Inspired by Michel Despland's teachings at Concordia University, I embarked on a research journey that led me to explore Bellah's work in depth. This journey culminated in my desire to interview Matteo Bortolini and Galen Watts, providing a platform to discuss Bellah's legacy and its implications for understanding religion and society in the modern world.
Ken Wilber's work, while influential, should be viewed separately from the Integral Life community. While Integral Life operates as a lifestyle enclave, Wilber's integral theory offers a comprehensive framework that bridges gaps among various disciplines, including psychology, sociology, and philosophy. His theories provide an overarching model that seeks to create a synthesis of knowledge, integrating insights from different fields into a coherent whole.
Wilber's integral approach, often referred to as AQAL (All Quadrants, All Levels), emphasizes the inclusion of multiple perspectives and dimensions of human experience. This framework can be applied to academic research and interdisciplinary studies by offering a structured method to analyze complex phenomena. For example, in psychology, Wilber's model can help integrate diverse theories from cognitive, developmental, and transpersonal psychology, providing a more integral understanding of human development.
In sociology, Wilber's integral theory can bridge the gap between micro and macro analyses, connecting individual experiences with broader social structures. By incorporating elements from cultural studies, critical theory, and systems theory, Wilber's approach enhances our understanding of societal dynamics and their influence on personal and collective development.
In philosophy, Wilber's work offers a meta-theoretical perspective that synthesizes various philosophical traditions. His integral philosophy draws from both Western and Eastern schools of thought, creating a dialogue between analytical and contemplative approaches. This synthesis allows for a more nuanced exploration of fundamental questions regarding existence, knowledge, and ethics.
By focusing on the broader academic and philosophical implications of Wilber's theories, we can appreciate their potential to enrich and deepen interdisciplinary research. While Integral Life caters to personal growth and lifestyle interests, Wilber's integral theory serves as a robust foundation for scholars and researchers seeking to transcend disciplinary boundaries and foster a more integrated understanding of complex issues.
Thus, examining contemporary spiritual communities like Integral Life through Bellah's lens allows us to better appreciate the tension between personal needs and communal commitments, while recognizing the broader academic contributions of Wilber’s work to the fields of psychology, sociology, and philosophy.