Lament for a Nation

George Grant, Canadian Nationalism, & Religion in Canada

George Grant 1918-1988

Summary

This essay delves into the profound impact that George Grant's philosophy and body of work has had on my intellectual development and some of my ongoing research at the Metapattern Institute. It intertwines my personal and academic experiences with reflections on the 2008/2012 financial crisis and student protests in Quebec, the discovery of Michael Brooks after his fallout with the integral movement, and

Matthew McManus

's ongoing research on the rise of postmodern conservatism. Furthermore, the essay provides a commentary on the current political landscape and features insights gleaned from various interviews on my podcast with influential scholars in the field of religious studies, contrasting the Canadian and American contexts while highlighting George Grant's enduring legacy.

Introduction

The exploration of Canadian intellectual history reveals a tapestry of thinkers who have profoundly shaped the nation's identity and discourse. Among these figures, George Grant emerges as a philosopher of particular resonance, especially within the context of contemporary theological and philosophical debates. His work, imbued with a melancholic yet insightful tone, interacts with my own intellectual pursuits in ways that parallel my engagement with other influential figures like Charles Davis and Marc Lalonde. While Davis and Lalonde ignited a deep passion for Jürgen Habermas philosophy's impact on the field of religious studies, catholic theology, and integral humanism– Grant's writings spurred me into a deep dive into the complexities of nationalism, the implications of technology, and the uncertain trajectory of Canadian sovereignty.

Zen Buddhism & Concordia University

In 2002, I began studying at the Montreal Zen Center under the guidance of Albert Low. This period marked the beginning of several spiritual experiences deepening my connection to Zen Buddhism and my Catholic roots. However, between 2006 and 2012, I experienced a personal identity crisis as a Westerner practicing Zen and growing-up in a family deeply wounded by the Catholic Church in Quebec. This crisis led me back to university to pursue a religious studies degree at Concordia University, where I eventually met Marc Lalonde and Michel Despland. Through their mentorship, I was introduced to the complex work of Charles Davis on critical theology, Jacques Maritain's work on integral humanism, and Robert Bellah's work on the sociology of religion. This journey also led me to discover the works of Gregory Baum and Tracey Rowland, which further enriched my intellectual pursuits and interests in Catholic theology.

The 2008 Financial Crisis & 2012 Quebec Student Protests

The 2008 financial crisis and the 2012 Quebec student protests were pivotal moments in my intellectual journey, catalyzing significant shifts in my academic interests and philosophical pursuits. The economic turmoil triggered by the financial crisis had a profound impact on my thinking, leading me to question the sustainability and ethical implications of liberal capitalism and the American neoliberal economic order. Witnessing the widespread economic instability and social unrest that ensued, I became increasingly disillusioned with the prevailing economic and political order. This period of introspection prompted me to delve into alternative economic and political theories, particularly those that offered a critique of capitalism from a religious perspective and explored more equitable and sustainable models.

The 2012 Quebec student protests, with their calls for accessible education and social justice, further fueled my desire for a more just and equitable society. Observing the students' passionate advocacy for social change deepened my commitment to social and political activism. These experiences, both the financial crisis and the student protests, led me to re-evaluate my academic priorities and pursue research that aligned with my newfound social, political, and ongoing interests in religion.

George Grant's Lament for a Nation

It was during this time that I developed a keen interest in the work of George Grant, a Canadian philosopher known for his religious critique of modernity and liberal capitalism. Grant's seminal work, "Lament for a Nation," resonated with my growing concerns about the impact of liberal capitalism on Canadian society. Grant's critique of American imperialism and the erosion of Canadian national sovereignty struck a chord with me, as I witnessed the adverse effects of the financial crisis on various individuals, my own family, and Canada’s ongoing dependence on economic and military security. Grant's emphasis on the need for a balance between individualism and religious communitarian outlook provided me with a philosophical framework to understand and critique the socio-economic changes brought about by the crisis.

Current Political Reflections

Reflecting on the current political landscape, the rise of postmodern conservatism and the return of Donald Trump to the White House with JD Vance highlight the urgency of Grant's insights. The resurgence of identity-oriented and reactionary alt-right movements and the increasing polarization in Western societies underscore the relevance of Grant's critique of modernity and liberal capitalism. His emphasis on the ethical responsibilities of nations and the need for a balanced approach to individualism and communitarian outlook offers a valuable framework for understanding the challenges facing Canada and the world.

As I delved deeper into the works of George Grant, I came across the writings of Michael Brooks and Matt McManus. Brooks' insightful critiques of contemporary politics and McManus' analyses of postmodern conservatism and the alt-right movement further enriched my understanding of the socio-political landscape. Their works provided additional perspectives on the challenges facing modern society and the need for a balanced approach to individualism and my own developing integral humanism outlook.

On Technology & Religion in Canada

Through various interviews on my podcast with influential religious studies scholars in Canada and the United States, I gained valuable insights into the current state and ongoing debates within the field. These discussions allowed me to explore the intersections between theology, philosophy, and socio-political issues, deepening my understanding of George Grant's complex legacy and the key differences between religious studies in Canada and the United States.

Grant's intellectual contributions extend beyond academic theory; his work reflects a profound engagement with the core tensions and anxieties of the modern age. He transcends simplistic nationalism in his exploration of cultural identity, political power, and the ethical responsibilities of nations. Similarly, his critique of technology moves beyond mere technophobia to examine how technological advancements shape human values, social structures, and the essence of humanity, as well as the role of religion in society.

Conclusion

George Grant's work continues to resonate deeply within contemporary discussions on nationalism, technology, and the role of religion in society and political theory. His insights provide not only a critique but also a call to action for preserving our humanity amidst global economic and technological pressures. My engagement with his writings has profoundly shaped my intellectual development, offering frameworks to navigate personal crises, academic pursuits, and broader socio-political landscapes. As we move forward in an increasingly complex world, Grant's emphasis on ethical responsibility and a balanced and integral approach to human flourishing remains ever relevant.

Grant's reflections on the fate of Canadian sovereignty are imbued with a sense of both lament and urgency - which also prompted these reflections. He recognizes the achievements and potential of Canadian culture while simultaneously acknowledging its internal contradictions and the looming threats to its continued flourishing. His work serves as a poignant reminder of the need for critical self-reflection and a re-evaluation of societal priorities in the face of unprecedented challenges like ours today.